Eighteenth Sunday of Ordinary Time (C) [Lk 12:13-21]
31.07.2022
The Parable of the Rich Fool
1. Theme in brief
Christian
attitude toward wealth
2. Focus Statement
We need to be on our guard against
all kinds of greed for possessions because our life does not consist in the
abundance of our possessions.
3. Explanation of
the text
According to today’s gospel, when someone in the crowd requests Jesus to tell his brother to divide the family inheritance with him, he refuses to be a “judge” or arbitrator in the property dispute between brothers, though other Rabbis used to do it in his time (12:13-14). Instead, he uses this request as an occasion to teach a lesson about the dangers of greed for wealth and the trap laid by it (12:15). He sees behind this dispute over land and property human tendencies toward greed or covetousness. In order to emphasize the foolishness of putting full trust in one’s wealth and fighting over land and property, he tells them the parable of the Rich Fool. Through this parable Jesus wants to teach the lesson that their quarrel over family inheritance would come to an end without his intervention, if they could root out greed from their hearts over possessions and show genuine love for each other.
This parable is about a rich man who is not rich enough. The so-called Rich Fool in this parable is in fact a Poor Rich Fool. He is rich in people’s or society’s sight but poor in God’s, or as Jesus says in this text he is “not rich toward God” (12:21). What exactly is the fault of this rich farmer? There is no hint in the parable to suggest that he has amassed his wealth by illegal/corrupt means or by paying unjust wages to his labourers. He must have gained it by his hard work. He seems to have become the envy of many neighbours because his fields have produced so abundant crops that he has no place to store them (12:17). After all, what is wrong in making plans and building “larger barns” for storing one’s “grain and goods” (12:18)? Yet, Jesus finds him at fault. His first fault is found in his relentless use of the first person pronouns "I" and "my." This is what he says in his self-talk after his land “produced abundantly” (12:16): “I will do this…. I will pull down…. I will build…. I will store…. my grain… my goods…. say to my soul….” (12:18-19). He uses the word "I" six times and the word "my" five times. For him everything is "I" and "my." This sort of self-chatting portrays him as a man who is totally preoccupied with self or one who is at the height of his selfishness or egoism.
This first fault leads to a second one: with the abundance of his wealth he believes that he can make his future totally secure. This makes him declare to his own soul his philosophy of life: "Soul, you have ample goods laid up for many years; relax, eat, drink, be merry" because nobody knows what will happen tomorrow (12:19). With all the wealth, he is so poor that he is unable exercise total control over his life. All his calculations and plans are shattered as he is interrupted by the Word of God, “This very night your life is being demanded of you,” that is, you are going to die (12:20). He sadly comes to know that his larger barns cannot save his life. He lately realizes his miscalculation: forget about tomorrow, tonight itself his life will end!
According to this story, God himself calls this rich man, “You fool” (12:20). The psalmist says that only “fools say in their hearts that there is no God“(Ps 14:1). This Rich Fool’s foolishness consists in keeping God “out of sight, out of mind” by placing his full trust and ultimate security in wealth and believing that it will save him from all troubles. He lives a life of practical atheism: when it comes to managing his life he relies on his possessions leaving God totally out of his schemes. In other words, his foolishness consists in forgetting the fact that he is not the master of his life and destiny and has no total control over it.
The egoistic outlook of this Rich Fool eliminates not only God from his consideration or scheme but also neighbours. His covetousness towards possessions makes him blind to the rights and needs of others. The thought that he needs to share at least something of his wealth with the less fortunate never enters his mind. He allows his possessions to possess him or the property he owned to own him. His total reliance on material possessions and money with a philosophy of life mentioned above (12:19) is the sign of a totally dissipated life as Luke tells in another place in his gospel (12:45).
4. Application to life
As it happens in the life of the Rich Fool, excessive greed can lead to the following consequences for us also. We can observe a number of “foolish” points in this man’s way of thinking and action-plan: (1) He fails to recognize where his wealth comes from. He lives a materialistic life-style and forgets that his wealth is God’s gift. It is the Lord who gives everything and the Lord who takes away (Job 1:21), sometimes all of a sudden. (2) He thinks that wealth is meant for only to build larger barns and store up goods for himself. It never occurs to him that when his existing barns are already filled with his goods, it is high time to share them with the have-nots. (3) He plans for an early retirement from duties because he considers the abundance of his wealth as his total security for the future, as if it would save him from any calamity. (4) He never thinks about the possibility that he may not live to enjoy what he has accumulated and somebody who never worked for it may enjoy it.
We can very well notice that the attitudes of this rich man towards wealth are totally contrary to Jesus’ teachings. He keeps God out of his schemes and thinks that all his wealth is his own achievement and not a blessing from God. He does not think of the possibility of sharing even a small portion of his wealth with the have-nots. This man has become a worshipper of the most popular gods of today: "I,” “My” and “Mine” – a sort of Unholy Trinity. He is called "fool" not because of the abundance of his wealth or his ambitious plans but because he considers finite and passing things as if they had an infinite and permanent value. In spite of such a wonderful scientific progress and technological advances of our times, today the whole of human race has become more vulnerable and fragile than before. Anywhere at any time a terrorist attack can take place in spite of meticulous security measures of our Governments. Life is full of uncertainty and insecurity. After all, nobody can fully control one’s own life neither with one’s own wealth nor achievements.
Therefore, in this parable Jesus teaches that if we want to avoid various kinds of greed, we must “take care” or watch out and “be on our guard” against its dominion over us (12:15). He insists that unless we are always vigilant against the onslaught of greed and resist its dominion over us with spiritual power that comes from God, we can become easy victims to its designs. As per Christian attitude, money and wealth are not exclusively for oneself. If we allow greed and covetousness to take control of our mind and hearts, it can produce the following consequences: (1) constant quarrels, disputes and court cases over money and property in our homes and neighbourhoods resulting in the failure of any advice, reconciliation and arbitration; (2) cases of unequal division of ancestral land among brothers in some families and grabbing of others’ land through intimidation; (3) temptation to acquire money and wealth by any available means, no matter how dubious or immoral they may be; (4) to be blind to the rights and needs of others, especially of the poor; (5) to forget to look beyond ourselves and be conscious of our stewardship or responsibility to share something of our wealth with the have-nots. Like the Rich Fool, excessive greed can take away any compassion for the needy. God does not bless us with sufficient wealth to hoard it for ourselves but to use a part of it for the service of others or building up of his Kingdom, where the poor who lack basic necessities of life and the poor in spirit (who need spiritual food) are taken care of. Then only, as Jesus says, we shall “be rich toward God” (12:21).
In our consumerist society today, we are constantly bombarded with the display of glamorous goods and are enticed with advertisements to acquire the latest gadgets. We fall victims to this allurement and acquire the latest goods by discarding the old ones. We forget the fact that our wealth gives us only a relative degree of security and comfort. By itself it does not produce genuine love, a good relationship with neighbours, a meaning in life, peace of mind and existential joy. During one of my social awareness seminars, when I asked some Catholic leaders to make two columns in their notebooks and write in the first column, the things money could buy and in the second, the things money could not, one of them wrote that money could buy both sin and virtue, and left the other column blank. One wonders how one can buy virtue with money. We can buy costly food to eat with our money but not appetite; a cosy bed to sleep in but not a peaceful sleep; and the best Bible but not faith in God’s Word. A boy may buy a girl and vice versa with money, but cannot buy genuine care, concern, forgiveness of hurts, mutual adjustments and self-sacrifice which are essential ingredients of a happy married life. We cannot buy all the precious virtues and values as well as character with money. Then why treat it as the be-all and end-all of life?
This is the reason why Jesus tells us to live by this principle: “One’s life does not consist in the abundance of possessions” (12:15). Any amount of accumulation of goods sufficient enough for ages to come will not produce real life. Life is not meant for accumulating wealth only or merely for self-enjoyment. As Jesus says, you are never sure “the things you have prepared, whose they will be” ultimately (12:20). Like the Rich Fool, we too sometimes have wrong priorities. What is the priority of our life? Life does not consist only in acquiring and accumulating wealth or eating and drinking. The rich man in today’s parable lives a life not only of egoism but also of hedonism and practical atheism. He represents people who are always at the service of dollars/ pounds/ euros/ rupees to such an extent that they are willing to bow to their demands at the cost of human relationships. They forget that the real purpose of our life is to become rich toward God by putting our total security in him alone and not in wealth, and by cultivating a spirit of detachment towards possessions. Ultimately our life is far superior to our possessions. It does not depend on our riches either.
The
message of today’s gospel calls upon us to set our priorities regarding
possessions. Riches are not bad in themselves, but can become bad if we put our full
security in them instead of God, and if they are used exclusively for our own selfish
purposes. For that matter, even poverty does not make one free from
selfishness. While some poor people generously share even the little they have,
others become greedy toward those little things. The problem is not
owning possessions as such but allowing our possessions to possess
us. It is our foolishness to place our full trust and security in wealth
(money) and to believe that it will save us from all troubles and make us truly
happy. Our true
value is not determined by our valuables. All our plans and human
calculations made by trusting in the abundance of accumulated wealth will be
shattered like the Rich Fool if we put God out of our scheme of things. The
real contrast as well as the battle is between being rich in the world’s eyes
and being rich in God’s. As God is rich in mercy, as his children, we too are
called to be rich in showing mercy towards the poor by sharing what we have,
instead of storing it up only for ourselves.
What
about the right use of money? Money represents value. What we do with our money
shows what we value in your heart. If we value only eating, drinking and making
merry, then we spend money for these things extravagantly, making a public
display of it especially at weddings and parties. If we value service to
neighbours, helping the poor and the needy, and participation in the mission of
the Church, then we shall spend our money for these things also. Jesus says:
“Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also” (Lk 12:34).
How and where we spend our money shows what we value the most in life. The
question is whether we value our possessions more than God, or whether we value
God more than our possessions.
5. Response to God's Word
What is our attitude towards money and wealth? Do we trust in wealth more than in God? Do we have a sense of detachment towards wealth so as not to put our full security and trust in it? What is the priority of our life? Is it amassing wealth, eating and drinking or something beyond that? Do we seriously try to root out greed from our hearts? Do we share something of what we have with those who don’t have even that much?
6. A Prayer
Deliver us, O Lord, from all covetousness and from attachment to possessions. You alone are our greatest treasure and portion. All that we have and we are is your gift. Grant that we may make good use of your gifts which come also in the form of material blessings you give us. May we use them generously for your glory and share a part of them with the less fortunate ones. Amen.