Twenty-second Sunday of Ordinary Time (B)
[Mk7:1-8.14-15.21-23]
01.09.2024
Tradition of the Elders and True Defilement
1. Theme in brief
The religion of the heart versus
lip-service
2. Focus Statement:
The
essence of true religion is not mere observation of rituals and traditions but
service to the neighbour, and the roots of all evil are in human heart, not in
the body.
3. Explanation of the text
Today’s gospel presents Jesus’ views on inner purity of heart in contrast to the outer purity of ritual cleanliness of the Jews. The text begins with the criticism
or accusation levelled by the Pharisees and scribes from
Besides the laws of the OT, the good Jews were expected to observe all
the rules and regulations formulated by the scribes regarding every possible
situation in life called “tradition
of the elders.” One of
those rules was about not eating with unwashed or ‘defiled’ hands (7:2). This rule was made and observed not out of hygienic
consideration to prevent people from eating with dirty hands. It was a ritual or ceremonial washing to get rid of all defilement from
outsiders. When the pious Jews returned from market they had to clean
themselves and everything else brought from there (7:4) to get rid of the contamination acquired by the touch of unclean Gentiles. The
same ritual washing applied to vessels (7:4). This ritual reminded the Jews
that they were ‘special’ people set
apart for God and separated from others who were ‘unclean.’ Since the disciples of Jesus were not observing this ritual washing, the
critics understood that they had
not set themselves apart for God.
Referring to Prophet Isaiah (Is 29:13), Jesus stated that God wanted not
mere lip-service but heart-service
(7:6). He called their
traditions merely “human precepts” or "human tradition” and not really
religious “doctrines” or "the commandments of God" (7:7-8). Whereas
for the scribes and Pharisees these traditions were the essence of religion,
for Jesus inner purity was the essence. They believed that
meticulous observation of the minutest rules handed down by elders put them in
God’s good books, and breaking them was sin. In fact, they were imposing
human teaching or words as God’s Word or doctrine (7:7), and abandoning more
serious commandments of God. They had substituted human teaching for divine teaching (7:8). He called them “hypocrites” (7:6), because this word was used for actors in a drama whose actual
self was hidden behind a mask. Like actors they were pretenders who appeared to be other than who they really
were.
The scribes had done enough home-work to explain in minute details the
Mosaic Law that forbids consumption of certain foods as ‘unclean’. According to
Jesus, not only the tradition of the elders but also any distinction between ‘clean’ and ‘unclean’ food was irrelevant for true religion. He declared the classification of clean and unclean
food in the Law of Moses null and void. For him all foods were clean (7:19). It
was not the so-called ‘unclean’ food that went into people’s stomachs which defiled
them but what came out of the depth of their hearts
(7:15, 18-20). In other words, according to him, it was not the food that people
ate without ceremonial washing that made them unclean, but the evil thoughts and feelings that came out of their hearts.
At the end, Jesus went on to list the things that came out of people’s
polluted minds or hearts that made them unclean. The evil intentions coming out of the heart (many of them derived
from the Ten Commandments) can be understood as: sexual abuses, dishonesty and deceitfulness,
anti-life deeds, coveting to possess what others have, nursing an evil desire
to inflict harm on others, cunningness, wickedness, envying with an evil eye, pride
that considers oneself better than others, etc. (7:22). He announced that holiness came from within (from the heart) and not from outside, especially by
observing rules.
4.
Application to life
In today’s gospel, Jesus makes a distinction between those who consider
religion as only observance of rituals, customs and traditions (as Pharisees
and scribes considered), and those who consider it as a spiritual force to
serve others and to practice
the spiritual values
contained in it. We
are constantly in danger of equating true religion with mere external
observances like
customarily or routinely going to church, saying prayers, lighting candles,
offering masses, etc. Though these practices are expressions of our faith in
God, they may not necessarily make us good and holy persons, if our hearts are away from God and neighbours. Jesus
teaches us that true religion does not consist in observing external rules and
traditions alone, but comes from the heart. If we keep enmity, bitterness,
grudges, pride, hatred, etc., in our hearts and only externally follow all the
religious practices, customs, rituals and traditions, God may tell us, as Jesus
told the scribes and Pharisees quoting the Prophet Isaiah, that we honour him
with our lips, but our hearts are far from him. When we worship, God looks at
our hearts, not our external observance. Instead of keeping ourselves busy in
ritual purification, in trivial rules and regulations and arguments over them,
Jesus asks us to get back to the basics or essentials of our faith and purify our hearts
first. If somebody attends daily Mass, then goes home to quarrel with the
person with whom he/she always quarrels, it is understood that this is not a
religion of the heart. Surely, God is not pleased with this type of worship!
For Jesus holiness meant a purity of heart. His views on holiness differed radically from the religious
leaders of Judaism. The Pharisees and the scribes thought that holiness before
God could be achieved merely by observing laws and traditions regarding ritual
purity. According to Jesus, just by observing external rules and traditions
meticulously nobody becomes holy. He tells us to eat whosoever is palatable to
us, but keep God’s commandments. For him holiness could be achieved only when
our love for God results in loving our neighbours which is proved by our care for the
needy and the afflicted, uncompromising stand on certain moral issues, etc. Pope
Francis, in his recent Apostolic Exhortation titled “Gaudete et Exultate”
(Rejoice and be Glad) says that holiness is accessible to all; holiness is
attainable by all. He calls us to go beyond the canonized saints and recognize
"the saints next door” – Christians who live a saintly life not by doing
big and dramatic actions but by living the gospel values and bearing witness to Christ in so many small and little
ways in their own state of life or situation. You too can be holy by showing
God’s love to others in a small way, even by your “patience” and “charming
smile,” as the Pope says.
In today’s text we hear Jesus directly calling the scribes and Pharisees
hypocrites (7:6) – actors in a drama who hide their real face behind masks. Like him, though we cannot call anybody
directly a hypocrite, all of us, including me, have elements of hypocrisy in us. Are we not becoming mere actors
or pretenders in a ‘religious drama’ if we observe all the regulations of our
religion (like regular attendance at the Sunday Service, novenas and
charismatic prayers), but just close our eyes and do nothing when injustice done under our nose, when the rights of the defenceless (including the
unborn and the terminally ill persons) are violated, when we see so much suffering and poverty in the world, when we become insensitive to the dire needs of others, when we
see highly corrupt or immoral practices around us? Instead of feeling powerless to do
anything, why not use the internet to send an objection, a concern, a support, an
encouragement, an opposition, a suggestion, an awareness, a warning or caution,
or a thought-provoking message through email, Facebook, WhatsApp, Twitter,
Blog, Website?
Also there may be other symptoms of hypocrisy in us: When we do not practice what we preach, or strictly demand
from others the norms of discipline and higher moral standards that we
ourselves do not practice; when we ourselves are not convinced or do not believe what we say in public
(often because of our position as parents and leaders); when we are so kind and
generous to outsiders but are harsh and miserly within our own families/ religious
communities; and when we pretend to be holy/ spiritual-minded/ pious/ faithful to our
vocation in the world outside, but are corrupt and unfaithful in our private life, etc. Yes, we have
a public face and a private face. How hard it is for all of us to heed to
Jesus’ demand to take out our masks!
According to Jesus, the root cause of all evil is in human mind or heart, not body. For him, what makes us
unclean is not what we eat but what we think, and impurity is a matter of the heart and not of
the stomach. In biblical symbolism, "heart" is
considered the centre of the human person where his/her sentiments, intentions
and will-power dwell. Therefore, it is sins
(evil) which come out of the heart which truly defile a person, not what type of food he/she eats. Food comes from outside,
enters the stomach and does not remain there. But sin begins in the heart,
enters deeply into it and remains there until it is rooted out by a painful
process of repentance. Both our inner purity
and inner impurity are manifested in outward behaviour, either good or bad. Good intention, good action; evil intention, evil action.
Before committing an evil action, first an evil thought or imagination is
generated in the mind. It is by giving consent to this thought or acting according to this evil intention, we commit
sins or indulge in wrongdoing. That is why Jesus says, what goes into the mouth
does not defile a person, but what comes out of it does.
All of us have a wonderful ‘friend’ inside us called “conscience” that rejoices when we do something
good, and pricks or stings when we do something wrong. No doubt, we have an ‘enemy’ too inside us
called “evil intentions.” This ‘enemy’ generates wicked thoughts that
result in wicked words and actions. When we have an ill-formed conscience, it
stops pricking even if we do something terribly wrong. Our human nature is
inclined to all sorts of evil desires, thoughts and actions enlisted by Christ
in today’s gospel. Even the most basic human faculty such as love can be
exercised either with a clean heart and selfless thoughts, or with a polluted
heart with selfish
motives. Left to ourselves we are unable to control all these evil
inclinations.
In modern times, our minds can get easily contaminated because they are so much exposed to
sex, violence, crime, corruption, etc., due to the influence of mass media. If
not controlled, this ‘inner enemy’ propelled by the outer force (exposure to
evil) is capable of contaminating our conscience and cutting off our communion with
God. Therefore we are always in need of ‘inner cleansing’ or a purification of the heart with the help of God’s
grace. Here purity means a purity of mind and intentions. We are to regularly
nip our evil intentions in the bud itself, so that our actions do not become
evil or sinful. If our intentions are pure, our action will be virtuous. We
need to purify our ‘polluted’ minds regularly by prayer and reflection on God’s
Word. The list of vices mentioned by Jesus in today’s gospel (cf. above) is
strong enough to make us realize our need for a self-examination and self-purification.
Finally, the tension between the legalistic and literal understanding of the law and its true spirit noticed in today’s gospel text, exists
even today. Instead of living the weightier values of the gospel, or practicing
its spirituality, there are people who fanatically or stubbornly hold on to
certain religious rules, customs and practices by insisting on the letter of
the law. Though rules, regulations, customs and traditions in religion and
society are good in their own way, they are not immutable. It is good to examine whether we are
open to change a tradition according to the signs of the times. It is necessary to check whether we substitute
what is essential with what is trivial or what is subject to change. As Jesus said it is important to
consider obedience to God’s Word as more important than obedience to ‘human
precepts’.
5. Response to God's Word
Do we seriously try to practice any of the gospel-values by making a
choice in our real life or confine ourselves to merely paying lip-service to
them? Do we emphasize the practice of gospel-values in our life more than the
emphasis we give to religious rules, customs, traditions and rituals? Do move from merely hearing the Word to
becoming the doers of the Word? Have we become victims to the vices mentioned
by Jesus in today’s gospel without seriously bothering to strike at their root?
Do we regularly purify our ‘polluted’ minds by prayer, reflection on God’s Word
and the sacraments?
6.
A prayer
Create in me a clean heart, O God, and put a new and right spirit within
me. Purify my mind and its understanding that I may be able to distinguish
between what is right and what is wrong, holy and unholy, worldly and heavenly,
secular and spiritual, selfish and loving. Grant that I may be able to make
positive decisions to use my bodily, mental and spiritual faculties according
to your will and not according to my selfish and momentary desires. Amen.